Page 1 of 1
Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2022 6:49 am
by Dwight
In a drawing (SW2022), I find that when I apply a hole callout to a hole cut with an extrude feature (not hole wizard) I get a format I don't want (adds "THRU" to the callout). I can't find where this format is controlled. I don't see anything in calloutformat.txt that seems to apply to an extrude cut. Anyone know if this format can be changed and how to do it?
I would like to change this because we have quite a few engineers here who will not know to edit the callout.
Thanks
Dwight
Re: Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2022 8:36 am
by JSculley
From the Knowledge Base:
======================================
Solution Id: S-068143
Product: SOLIDWORKS 2020 Network Installation
Created: 2/12/2015
Technically Reviewed Date: 3/10/2022
Area: Part
Sub-Area: Hole
Question: Is it possible to remove the suffix "THRU" from hole callouts of simple through holes or holes created using cut-extrude features?
Answer:
Hole callouts for simple holes (geometry based holes) are always defined by their geometry. The callout syntax format is a combination of "Diameter symbol + Diameter value + Depth information." Users cannot modify this format, as it is hard-coded into SOLIDWORKS®. The workaround is to delete the “THRU” text manually after inserting the callout.
==========================================
Re: Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2022 9:18 am
by Glenn Schroeder
JSculley wrote: ↑Wed Nov 30, 2022 8:36 am
The workaround is to delete the “THRU” text manually after inserting the callout. . .
. . . or just use the Smart Dimension tool instead of Hole Callout.
Re: Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2022 3:55 pm
by Dwight
JSculley wrote: ↑Wed Nov 30, 2022 8:36 am
From the Knowledge Base:
======================================
Solution Id: S-068143
Product: SOLIDWORKS 2020 Network Installation
Created: 2/12/2015
Technically Reviewed Date: 3/10/2022
Area: Part
Sub-Area: Hole
Question: Is it possible to remove the suffix "THRU" from hole callouts of simple through holes or holes created using cut-extrude features?
Answer:
Hole callouts for simple holes (geometry based holes) are always defined by their geometry. The callout syntax format is a combination of "Diameter symbol + Diameter value + Depth information."
Users cannot modify this format, as it is hard-coded into SOLIDWORKS®. The workaround is to delete the “THRU” text manually after inserting the callout.
==========================================
Thanks, JSculley.
Re: Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2022 3:59 pm
by Dwight
Glenn Schroeder wrote: ↑Wed Nov 30, 2022 9:18 am
. . . or just use the Smart Dimension tool instead of Hole Callout.
Sure. It's often not obvious how the hole was made, which makes it hard to pick the method. I'd prefer that hole callout would work only on hole wizard holes, or there was a way to set the format.
Dwight
Re: Hole callout format for round cut extrudes (not hole wizard)
Posted: Fri Sep 22, 2023 6:24 pm
by CarrieIves
Related - In SolidWorks 2022, if you have two cut extrudes to create a counterbore, you can use the hole callout to create a hole callout with the counterbore symbol and depth. (You have to pick the outer cut for it to work, I think.) It will not let you apply a tolerance to more than one of the dimensions though.
Also, if you are using dual dimensions, you don't get the dual dimensions on both.
SPR1250812
Image below shows two different counterbore holes that were created with cut extrude features. (It made sense based on how the design progressed and that these were not standard holes.)